College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Thanks to negligent pilots, flying may not be as safe as we think

By Kirkland Carter

Print this article

Published: Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Updated: Tuesday, November 10, 2009

The two Northwest Airlines pilots who missed their destination by 150 miles two weeks ago have been suspended.  The FAA suspended the two for “operating in a reckless manner that endangered the lives and property of others,” according to the Washington Post. 

It is presumed that Delta, Northwest’s parent company, will fire them, but I believe that the pilots, found to have been so egregiously negligent, should serve jail time.

The incident occurred on Oct. 22.  Two days later, the co-pilot was quoted as saying that the two were not arguing or sleeping, as many had speculated. 

The Air Line Pilots Association, the pilots’ union, has a strict “no comment” policy regarding in-flight incidents. 

The loose-lipped pilot made another terrible decision by straying from the policy.  In my opinion, this only underscores his recklessness. 

If they were not sleeping, and they were not arguing, what were they doing?  The two pilots claimed to be in a “concentrated period of discussion.” 

They claimed to have been discussing the flight scheduling procedure and admitted to using their laptop computers, according to a Delta Air Lines press release.  I cannot see how they would be so enthralled with a flight scheduling procedure that they would both lose track of time. 

Delta’s Oct. 26 press release also states that “using laptops or engaging in activity unrelated to the pilots’ command of the aircraft during flight is strictly against the airline’s flight deck policies and violations of that policy will result in termination.” 

Credit Delta for firing these two, which I’m sure they will, but is that sufficient?  We should be proactive and increase the penalty for such wanton acts.

Chris Railey, a senior at the prestigious Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University, said, “[Pilots] must be in constant communication with their dispatcher according to FAA Regulations.” 

Don’t the pilots know how long the flight will be prior to departure?  “Yes, based on the winds and the performance of the plane, we can pretty accurately predict how long the flight should be.” 

“In fact, [that’s] how the dispatcher knows how much fuel to put on the plane-they can’t just fill it up or it would be overweight…[they’re] lucky that they had enough fuel to fly for another two hours after they missed the airport,” he added.

The Delta Pilots Union issued a statement saying that “At no time were the passengers, crew, or aircraft in danger.” 

I think running out of gas could be dangerous.  Not to mention the fact that two fighter jets were alerted, but never took off. 

After all, why send fighter jets after a wayward aircraft if blowing it out of the sky is not a possibility?  These people were very much in danger.

This is criminal negligence.  There should be legislation allowing for prosecution of pilots who put others’ lives in danger.  In almost every major tragedy, authorities look back to a point in time when something could have been done to prevent it.

If we do not act, then we are left to react, and the consequences will be fatal.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

5 comments

Your name
Thu Nov 12 2009 22:15
It seems like the only solution our society can come up with anymore is - there ought to be a law for that, lets pass legislation, or put them in jail. I haven't seen the statistics lately but, I believe we still have more people in our jails than any other nation in the world. I don't know if that's industrial or actually includes 3rd world countries. We probably build six or eight jails to every university or college that is built. What's wrong with this picture? I think we should educate not incarcerate.
Just Another Pilot
Tue Nov 10 2009 20:32
Should we place the writer in jail if he has ever used his cell phone or sent a text message while driving?
Iceman
Tue Nov 10 2009 20:27
I like how this misinformed writer quotes a senior at Embry Riddle. Like he has thousands of hours of experience piloting anything. Do you really think that a pilot wants to be reckless or kill him or herself? How many thousands of flights flew around the world safely today and every day, no one ever mentions that, it is taken for granted. The cost of a ticket today is the same as it cost in 1972, look it up! Yes, they are going to be reprimanded and surely lose their jobs, but don't punish the thousands who do it right.
Tcat
Tue Nov 10 2009 18:39
"just a pilot" has stated it correctly. The writer of the article engages in a basic tatic we are seeing more and more. Pile one soapbox on top of another, climb up, start shouting, and make what happened appear more sensational than it really was. The writer appears VERY concerned and truly outraged. Wriring on this manner places news in the ALL CAP, BOLD mode. Solves nothing, but makes the writer look good; at least to a few.
just a pilot
Tue Nov 10 2009 14:39
Your request it wanton!!! Jail time give me a break!! I am not excusing the pilots at all and yes they deserve to be reprimanded. What your seeing is just the beginning, incidents such as this or perhaps worse, i.e Colgan 3407 in Buffalo, are just the begining. What we are seeing are the ramifications of the constant concessions, over worked, not adequately rested, and stressed out pilots!! You want your cheap ticket, have at it!! As an airline pilot for a major US carrier I can attest to this first hand.






log out